 | The referee whistles for the end of the match | |
| 90' |  | New York City FC: RJ Allen(in) - Rodney Wallace(out) |
| 89' | | New York City FC: Frédéric Brillant(in) - Maxi Morález(out) |
| 86' | | Columbus Crew: Adam Jahn(in) - Nicolai Naess(out) |
| 86' | | New York City FC: Miguel Camargo(in) - Sean Okoli(out) |
| 81' | | Columbus Crew: Niko Hansen(in) - Ethan Finlay(out) |
| 81' | | Columbus Crew: Kekuta Manneh(in) - Ethan Finlay(out) |
| 79' |  | Maxime Chanot (New York City FC) is shown a yellow card |
| 76' |  | GOAL New York City FC: Jack Harrison (New York City FC) scores! |
| 64' | | GOAL New York City FC: Yangel Herrera (New York City FC) scores! |
| 49' | | GOAL Columbus Crew: Ola Kamara (Columbus Crew) scores! |
 | 2nd half begins | |
 | The 1st half ends | |
| 44' | | Jukka Raitala (Columbus Crew) is shown a yellow card |
| 29' | | GOAL Columbus Crew: Federico Higuaín (Columbus Crew) scores! |
| 17' | | Yangel Herrera (New York City FC) is shown a yellow card |
| 8' | | GOAL New York City FC: Jack Harrison (New York City FC) scores! |
| 2' | | Ben Sweat (New York City FC) is shown a yellow card |
 | The match begins | |
